The Science Snail
  • Home
  • Science
  • Philosophy
  • About
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

 Life does not violate the second law of thermodynamics

8/23/2013

4 Comments

 
The second law of thermodynamics states that the entropy (S), a measure of disorder, increases during any spontaneous process in an isolated system. ​
Picture
We can view the entire universe as an isolated system, leading to the conclusion that the entropy of the universe is tending to a maximum. However, all living things maintain a highly ordered, low entropy structure. The emergence of life in our universe therefore seems to be at odds with this thermodynamic law. If all spontaneous chemical processes result in increased disorder, it may seem unclear how highly ordered structures could be produced, let alone maintained. Although this view is not uncommon, there is no real contradiction between life and the second law of thermodynamics. The above statement of the second law works only in an isolated system. The Earth and all life on it are not isolated systems, so an alternative statement of the second law must be developed. We can start with the axiom that spontaneous processes increase the entropy of the universe, beyond the entropy change due to the heat transfer (q) alone.
Picture
Where T is the temperature of the system. Now, recall the first law of thermodynamics (the first law is discussed in more detail in my article about the molecular difference between heat and work):
Picture
Where U is the internal energy, w is the work, P is the pressure, and V is the volume. If this equation is combined with the above inequality for the entropy change, it can be shown that 
Picture
It is a reasonable approximation to assume that the chemical processes in biological systems occur at constant temperature and pressure. This makes the above result extremely convenient. Notice that if T and P are held constant
Picture
For simplicity, we define U – TS + PV as a new quantity called the Gibbs energy (G). The quantity U + PV is defined as the enthalpy (H). For our purposes this is a more useful statement of the second law. This result works in any system with constant temperature and pressure, regardless of whether or not it is isolated. A process is spontaneous when its change in Gibbs energy is negative.
Picture

ARTICLE CONTINUES BELOW ADVERTISEMENT

Now, let’s return to the issue of life’s highly ordered structure. Consistent with the idea of the second law, the highly ordered structural components of lifeforms are constantly degrading. New structural components must be continually synthesized to replace them. In fact, life has even been defined through this property, such as Pier Luisi’s definition [1]:

A system can be said to be living if it is able to transform external matter/energy into an internal process of self-maintenance and production of its own components.

The issue is how highly ordered structural components can be created when only processes which increase the universe's disorder occur spontaneously. Certainly, building complicated biological structures and biomolecules is not by itself spontaneous process. However, such processes can be driven forward by the input of work ("useful" energy), in turn generated through other spontaneous processes. Therefore, the highly ordered nature of life is possible through this coupling. Note that a net gain in entropy is still attained.The conversion of energy into work is not 100% efficient; some energy is always dissipated as unusable heat which increases the entropy of the universe. Living things, therefore, may actually be thought of as heat-dissipating machines, maintaining their order through the production of even larger amounts of disorder. A practical example of this principle follows.

​In order for heterotrophs (such as ourselves) to stay alive, we must metabolize food. This provides the required work required to maintain our highly ordered structure. For instance, consider the aerobic respiration of glucose. The reaction below, of course, skips over a very large number of intermediates. However, this is unimportant since G, H and S are all state functions (they depend only on the present state, not the path through which it was achieved). 
Picture
Entropy increases in this reaction. This can be seen qualitatively by how the total number of molecules increases. Furthermore, this reaction has a negative enthalpy change (it releases energy to the environment). Therefore the Gibbs energy change must be negative. The Gibbs energy change associated with synthesizing life's structural components is surely positive. However, its magnitude could not be greater than that of glucose respiration (plus any other metabolic sources of energy) since this work drives the synthesis of these components. As previously discussed, a portion of the released energy cannot be used to do work. Instead it is dissipated as heat and increases the entropy. Thus the total entropy of the universe increases despite the highly ordered structure of the organism being maintained.

The question which follows from that example, however, is how sugars like glucose are formed on Earth given the second law. Of course these are formed through photosynthesis which is driven by work from the sun. Fusion reactions occur in the sun, light elements combine to make heavier ones and there is a slight decrease in the total rest mass of the atoms. This releases an incredible amount of energy, some of which can be used by autotrophs on Earth to do work, like synthesizing glucose. Yet much of the energy released by the sun is not available to do work, dissipation of this heat increases the entropy of the universe. When the entropy produced by the sun's fusion is considered, there is no contradiction between life and the second law of thermodynamics. The common error that leads to this mistake is to forget that both the Earth and individual organisms are not isolated systems. Although biological systems have highly ordered structure, they are maintained by work derived from processes that produces even more disorder. The chemistry underlying all biological systems exactly follows the second law of thermodynamics.

References:
[1] Luisi PL. 2006. The emergence of life: From chemical origins to synthetic Biology. New York: Cambridge University Press, 25 p.




4 Comments
Ashutosh Pandey
11/26/2019 12:09:35 pm

एन्ट्रापी हमेशा व्यवस्था से अव्यवस्था की ओर जाती है। जैसे एक कप टूट सकता है परन्तु टूटे टुकड़ो से कप का निर्माण बिना ऊर्जा खर्च के संभव नहीं है। परन्तु हमारी इसी कल्पना में दोष है कप हमेशा अलग प्रकार से टूटेगा । एक ही प्रकार के टूकड़ो को पाने के लिए ऊर्जा खर्च करनी होगी। संक्षेप में एन्ट्रापी या क्वांटम भौतिकी के गहन विचारण से स्पष्ट होता है कि जिन प्रेक्षणो को हम आब्जेक्टिव समझते है, जिन के आधार पर भौतिकी के सिद्धान्तो का परीक्षण करते हैं वे वास्तव में सब्जेक्टिव है अर्थात प्रेक्षक पर निर्भर करते हैं। इससे यह रोमांचक निष्कर्ष निकलता है कि भौतिकी के सारे सिद्धान्त जिन्हें सार्वभौमिक समझा जाता है वे मात्र प्रेक्षक की विचार पद्धति पर निर्भर करते हैं।

Reply
DH
9/4/2022 10:19:29 pm

Google translation attempt from Hindi. (Is it close?)

"Entropy always moves from order to disorder. Like a cup can be broken but making a cup from broken pieces is not possible without the expenditure of energy. But there is a flaw in our imagination, the cup will always break in a different way. Energy has to be spent to get the same type of pieces. In short, it is clear from the deep consideration of entropy or quantum physics that the observations which we consider to be objective, on the basis of which we test the principles of physics, are actually subjective i.e. they depend on the observer. This leads to the exciting conclusion that all the principles of physics that are considered universal depend only on the observer's method of thinking."

Reply
Divorce lawyer fees in Chennai link
12/11/2021 04:00:42 am

Looking for a best Divorce Lawyer in Chennai? We have a team of experienced divorce lawyers for your problem solving.

Reply
Dakota K link
6/27/2022 04:41:51 pm

This is a great post tthanks

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Archives

    December 2022
    April 2022
    December 2021
    December 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    December 2019
    June 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    December 2016
    April 2016
    January 2016
    August 2015
    July 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    August 2013

    Categories

    All
    Biochemistry
    Biology
    Enzymology
    Finance
    Health
    Mathematics
    Organic Chemistry
    Physical Chemistry

    RSS Feed

    List of all articles

    Mathematics of compound interest

    Dynamic nuclear polarization in solid state NMR 

    Modelling a multi-state G protein signalling pathway

    Organic synthesis of Aspirin

    Distinguishing enzyme inhibition mechanisms


    ​Metformin total synthesis
    ​
    ​Ki, Kd, IC50, and EC50 values

    ​
    AZT: mechanism and synthesis


    Forecasting website ad revenue

    Km vs Kd

    The relationship between TV screen size and price

    ​Health benefits of green tea

    Synthesis of ibuprofen from benzene

    ​The mechanism of action of Eflornithine
    ​
    Synthesis of sucralose from sucrose


    Diluting a solution to Avogadro's limit
    ​
    The affect of mutation rate on evolutionary equilibrium

    ​
    Organic synthesis of indomethacin


    Probing protein-protein interactions in the yeast glycolytic metabolon

    Time course enzyme kinetics

    A generalized​ model for enzymatic substrate inhibition
    ​
    ​The basis of high thermostability in thermophilic proteins
    ​

    First order drug elimination kinetics
    ​
    Improving the efficiency of protein dialysis: constant dialysate replacement


    Mathematical modelling of evolution

    Calculating the optimum ddNTP:dNTP ratio in Sanger sequencing

    A mathematical model of hair growth

    Life does not violate the second law of thermodynamics


    Collagen and the importance of vitamin C

    Temperatures below absolute zero are surprisingly hot

    The molecular difference between heat and work

    Want to keep up to date with new articles? Subscribe to the monthly newsletter! ​

Subscribe to Newsletter

​© 2020 Copyright The Science Snail. All rights reserved.